The scenario is familiar. A demo impresses management: in a few weeks, a team has built an assistant that answers questions, summarizes documents, sorts requests. Everyone is excited. Six months later, the prototype has not moved. It still runs on a developer’s machine, a few people use it now and then, and the project is no longer really on the agenda.
This is so common it has a name: “POC purgatory”. The causes are rarely technical. They almost always come down to how the prototype was designed. This article reviews the most frequent reasons, then how to design a POC that has a real chance of reaching production.
Why prototypes get stuck
Demo data, not real data
A prototype is often built on a clean sample: a few hand-picked documents, clear examples, typical cases. In production, it meets the real data: crooked scans, contradictory information, badly worded requests, edge cases. The performance seen in the demo no longer holds, and confidence collapses.
No integration path
An assistant in a separate window, fed by hand through copy and paste, does not fit into daily work. As long as the prototype is not connected to the tools teams already use (CRM, email, ticketing), it remains a curiosity. Yet integration is often the longest piece of work, and it was not planned.
No owner
The POC was driven by a technical team or a consultant. Once the demo is done, nobody on the business side is responsible for keeping it alive, gathering feedback, deciding on changes. A tool without an owner always ends up abandoned.
No success metric
“It’s impressive” is not a decision criterion. Without a baseline or a success threshold set in advance, it is impossible to say whether the prototype is worth the investment needed to industrialize it. The project stays in limbo, neither approved nor dropped.
Costs discovered too late
The prototype cost almost nothing to run on a few dozen requests. Extrapolated to real volume, model usage, infrastructure and maintenance change the equation. If that calculation comes after the demo, it cools everyone down.
Security and compliance last
The prototype used a personal account, real data copied onto a laptop, a model hosted without a suitable contract. When it is time to go live, IT and the DPO discover the project and ask legitimate questions. Everything has to be redone, and the momentum is lost.
Nothing to track quality
Even when go-live happens, a system without monitoring degrades: documents change, usage evolves, errors go unnoticed. Users lose trust and go back to their old ways.
A POC that does not prepare for production proves only one thing: that the technology works. That was almost never the question.
Designing a production-ready POC
The answer is not to get rid of prototypes, but to design them from the start as the first step of a real project. In practice, five elements make the difference:
- A sample of real data: representative, with its flaws and hard cases, and handled within a proper security framework from day one.
- A success threshold set in advance: a measure of the current situation, and a quantified goal that will trigger the decision to continue or stop.
- An identified integration path: in which tool the output will be used, through which APIs, with which rights. Even if full integration comes later, it must be sketched during the POC.
- A named business owner: someone who will use the tool, be accountable for it, and carry the decision to industrialize.
- A budget for what comes next: an estimate of the industrialization cost and the running cost at real volume, presented alongside the POC results.
It also helps to cap the POC’s duration and schedule the decision meeting from the start. A prototype that runs indefinitely is a prototype that will never be decided on.
A concrete example
A services company wants to test an assistant that answers its advisors’ questions from its internal knowledge base. Rather than a demo on ten hand-picked documents, the POC is built on a real extract of the base, outdated documents included, and tested on around a hundred questions recently asked by advisors. The head of customer service is named project owner. The success threshold is set before starting, as a share of answers judged correct and sourced by the advisors themselves. The POC is deployed inside the ticketing tool for a small pilot group rather than in a separate interface.
After six weeks, the decision is easy to make: results are measured on real cases, the integration path is already validated, costs at real volume are known, and IT has been involved from the beginning. Going to production becomes a logical next step, not a new project.
Our recommendation
Before launching a POC, ask yourself one question: “if this prototype works, what happens the next day?”. If the answer is vague, the POC will prove the technology, but not the value. Spend a few more days on scoping to define the data, the success threshold, the integration, the owner and the running budget. That upfront time is what turns an appealing prototype into a tool people actually use.